Thursday, May 9, 2013

#3--Leverage



Bibliographic Information

Leverage by Joshua C. Cohen. Dutton Juvenile. (2011).

Price: $17.99 for hardback
Pages: 304 for hardback

Plot Summary

Danny Meehan is a talented high school gymnast who is determined to go to college on a full-ride gymnastics scholarship in order to prove to his father that gymnastics is worthwhile. One of the hardest workers on the team, Danny resents new recruit Ronnie as Danny and Ronnie are constantly being compared to one another as they are both quite small. While Ronnie wishes to be a good athlete he is also sensitive and a bit naïve making Danny shy away from him. But perhaps the ultimate reason why Danny doesn’t like Ronnie is because the jocks on the football team constantly bully and tease the two of them.

Transfer student Kurt Brodsky is, like Danny, a hard-working athlete although he is easily three times Danny’s size as Kurt is a football player. Plucked from an ill-funded  high school Kurt knows that if he works hard he can make a name for himself at his new school and forget his troubled past. Bounced around the foster care system Kurt has finally landed into a home which, while not ideal, is his best one yet. As such, Kurt is willing to do almost anything to ensure that he gets a shot at a good college.

Danny and Kurt form a strange friendship when Kurt sees Danny performing a daring move at a gymnastics meet and decides that he would like to learn how to perform a backflip. Danny agrees to teach him knowing that having a brawny football player on your side is always a good thing. While their friendship solidifies things become progressively worse for Danny as three star football players are determined to make his life miserable. Things reach a tipping point when one day Danny and Kurt see them commit an unspeakably evil act against Ronnie. Now they must decide whether to speak up and risk their reputations and lives or to let things lie.

Critical Evaluation

While difficult to get through Leverage provides a story that needs to be told. Although the stories of female rape seem to be constantly in the public eye those of male rape are not. As such, it is important that books, like Leverage, are written on the topic so that people can become more educated on the matter and help prevent future rapes. It can certainly be argued that Leverage is unnecessarily graphic but if it were not so I believe many readers would be confused over the abuse suffered by Ronnie, Danny, and Bruce especially as there are plenty of people who believe that male rape is nigh impossible. As a result, the details in Leverage serve the purpose of letting people know what situations can lead to male rape and what it is. However, while the novel centers on a rape scene there are other important scenes in the book as well. Kurt’s journey is intriguing as he must decide whether or not to speak up when he is only now starting to have a relatively normal life. In speaking up he knows that not only will he have to confront his horrific past but that the student body will most likely learn of it as well. Danny’s journey is equally interesting as he tries to convince his father that his passion for gymnastics is legitimate. Danny must walk the fine line of being part of a team while avoiding the bigger, abusive jocks in the locker room. He, too, is afraid to speak up as he is knows that if he should what was done to his teammate will also be done to him.

Perhaps one of the most important (and rare) elements in Leverage is the relationship between Kurt, a powerfully built star football player, and Danny, a small gymnast. Together, the two of them form a bond as they both appreciate each other’s athletic prowess, ethics, and friendship. Cohen has created one of those rare YA sports novels that shows that football players can be more than brutal, stupid thugs while also showing the value of other lesser-known sports. Ultimately, while Leverage might not be for everyone it is an important book that will interest plenty of readers, particularly male athletes.

Reader’s Annotation

When a series of cruel pranks escalates, causing the suicide of a ninth grade student, the up-and-coming star football player Kurt and dedicated gymnast Danny must decide whether or not to speak up.

About the Author

First time novelist Joshua C. Cohen was inspired to write Leverage when he read a news story about victims of abuse being turned on for reporting it. He originally wanted to be a professional gymnast but realized in college that he didn’t have the proper body type for the sport. He is currently a professional dancer and actor touring with famous companies like MOMIX.

To learn more about Joshua Cohen visit his website here.

Genre

Realistic fiction, Sports story

Readalikes

Raiders Night by Robert Lipsyte
·         Also about football players covering up abuse
Stupid Fast by Geoff Herbach
·         Another YA book about football although less dark than Leverage
Payback Time by Carl Deuker
·         A YA mystery involving a football player

Tags

10th grade, abuse in foster care, favoritism, football, foster care, goth, gymnastics, high school, male rape, Minnesota, rape, single father, stuttering

Awards Won/Lists On

2011—Cybils Award Nominee for Young Adult Fiction
2012—YALSA Best Fiction for Young Adults

Professional Reviews

Booklist (starred review)




School Library Journal

Booktalk Ideas

Kurt is Told That…
·         Football team will take care of him (22)
·         Homecoming inspires hope in others (105)
·         But what’s the truth?

We need to take matters into our own hands, says Bruce (61)

Gymnastics is a team sport too! (73, 75)

Bibliotherapeutic Usefulness

This could be used to help teens who have lost a friend due to suicide as well as those that have experienced severe bullying, torture, and rape. It could also be used to educate teens on what constitutes male rape.

Reading Level/Interest Level

Reading Level: 5th grade
Interest Level: 9th-12th grade

These levels are according to AR Bookfinder

Challenge Issues

This book includes the following potentially controversial elements:

·         Abusive father
·         Adult buying teens alcohol
·         Adults encouraging steroid use
·         Alcoholic father
·         Attempted murder
·         Bullying
·         Ethnic slurs
·         Favoritism between sons
·         Homosexual slurs
·         Mention of sex
·         Police officer physically abusing a teen & using intimidation tactics
·         Profanity
·         Racial slurs
·         Rape
·         Shooting guns while intoxicated
·         Single father
·         Special treatment for football players
·         Steroid use
·         Suicide
·         Torture
·         Underage drinking

Librarians can point out that while this book contains a multitude of controversial elements it also shows some football players in a positive light (such as Terrence and Kurt) which seems to be rare in YA literature. Additionally it contains a positive male role model in the form of Coach Nelson and discusses the importance of friendship and standing up for what is right.

Why Was This Included?

I read this because I was on a reconsideration committee for it however I was also interested in reading more about the world of sports as I have never participated on sports teams.

#4--Endgame



Bibliographic Information

Endgame by Nancy Garden. Harcourt Children’s Books. (2006).

Price: $17.00 for hardback
Pages: 304 for hardback

Plot Summary

Fourteen-year-old Gray Wilton hopes that his new life will be better than his old one. As he begins high school in a new town he wants to believe that the bullying he left behind in his old town will not follow him. He is determined to make better grades and possibly even convince his father to approve of him and his passion for archery and drumming. Gray quickly realizes, however, that his new school is possibly even worse than his old one. The bullies are still there although they may have different faces and his inability to make friends is also still present. The girl he has a crush on doesn’t seem to notice him and his perfect older brother still overshadows him. Gray feels trapped. He knows that his drumming will come to naught as his father will not allow him to practice, his grades are slowly declining, and the bullies will not let up. Gray knows there is only one thing he can do—take out all those who are causing him misery. Maybe then he will have a shot at a happy life.

Critical Evaluation

Endgame is one of the most powerful, emotionally charged young adult school shooting novels in publication today. Unlike other school shooting books the school shooter is still alive when the novel takes place. In fact, the book is primarily told from the shooter’s perspective unlike Give a Boy a Gun and Shooter. However, the main difference between Nancy Garden’s book and others like it is that Gray is a completely likable, normal teenager. He doesn’t fall in with a bad crowd, take unusual pleasure in shooting guns, or have an obsession with bleak poetry or dark song lyrics. Instead, Gray is simply a fourteen-year-old seeking his father’s elusive approval while muddling through an unkind school environment. Unlike his golden boy brother Gray cannot seem to make many friends. Through no fault of his own he’s mercilessly picked on by a subset of jocks while his two passions, archery and drumming, are unusual enough that he cannot find many other people interested in them.

Another difference between Endgame and other school shooting novels is that Gray had several people reach out to him on numerous occasions. For example, his band teacher, his brother, and his brother’s girlfriend all ask him at various times if he is okay. In an interview with his attorney, Gray explains that he knew that if he told anyone about the abuse he and his friend Ross suffered that they would be dead meat (p. 120). As a result, readers will feel a gamut of emotions while engrossed in the novel. Anger, of course, will be the most prominent as readers will not only feel anger towards the jocks and Gray’s father but with Gray as well. Because readers know that Gray received multiple opportunities to go to authority figures about his bullying they will feel even more upset when Gray decides that shooting people is his only option. Of course, readers will also feel sad for Gray as his father is terrible and abusive. Ultimately, the book will create conflicting emotions in readers as they will want to simultaneously wish Gray a light sentence for the abuse he has suffered as well as a heavy one for the tragedy he has caused.

Reader’s Annotation

When fourteen-year-old Grey feels trapped both at home and at school he feels like he has no choice but to kill the jock who is the main source of his suffering.

About the Author

Author of thirty-five books Nancy Garden is well-known in literature circles as she has won the Robert B. Downs Award for Intellectual Freedom, the Margaret A. Edwards Award for Lifetime Achievement, and the Katahdin Award for Lifetime Achievement amongst others. Annie on My Mind which details the story of two teens’ first romance is perhaps her most famous (and controversial) book. Garden is no stranger to censorship as Annie on My Mind ranked number 44 on ALA’s 100 Most Frequently Challenged Books from 1990 to 1999.

To learn more about Nancy Garden visit her website here.

And also read Cynthia Leitich Smith’s interview with Nancy Garden here.

Genre

Realistic fiction, School shooting novel

Readalikes

Shooter by Walter Dean Myers
·         The aftermath of a school shooting is examined through a series of interviews with the shooter’s friends
Quad by C.G. Watson & Carrie Gordon Watson
·         Six students are trapped in the student store while another student goes on a shooting spree.
Give a Boy a Gun by Todd Strasser
·         Told through multiple perspectives teachers, students, parents, and community members explore why two teens decided to hold their fellow students hostage at a school dance.

Tags

14 yr. old, archery, bullying, Connecticut, guns, jock culture, older brother, springer spaniel

Awards Won/Lists On

2006—School Library Journal Best Book of the Year
2007—New York Public Library Book for the Teen Age

Professional Reviews

Kirkus Reviews
Note: Kirkus lists the age range of this book as 19-20 year-olds.



The Horn Book

Booktalk Ideas

Gray’s Life
·         Dad’s disapproval (12-13, 39-40, 87)
·         Jocks pick on him & there are double standards (101)
·         He only had one friend & his dog
·         Dreams of becoming a drummer

Bibliotherapeutic Usefulness

This book could be used to help people understand why and how school shootings occur. It could be used to help victims of school shootings heal or to create awareness about bullying.

Reading Level/Interest Level

Reading Level: 5th grade
Interest Level: 9th-12th grade

These levels are according to AR Bookfinder

Challenge Issues

This book includes the following potentially controversial elements:

·         Profanity
·         Homosexual slurs
·         Father with anger issues
·         Bullying
·         Teacher that allows bullying
·         Physical fights
·         Discussion of virginity
·         Teen forced to drink paint
·         Teens deliberately run over a pet
·         Forced sexual assault

Librarians can point out that while the book contains many disturbing elements they are necessary in order for the reader to understand what made Gray snap. They also serve to illustrate the type of behavior that some schools allow. Hopefully, the book will lead to conversations about bullying and the responsibility of students, parents, teachers, and administrators.

Why Was This Included?

I included this book because it was required and because I wanted to compare it to other school shooting books like Give a Boy a Gun and Shooter.

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

#5--Divergent



Bibliographic Information

Divergent by Veronica Roth. Katherine Tegen Books. (2012).

Price: $9.99 for paperback
Pages:  576 for paperback

Note: This book was originally published in 2011. Also, the paperback is a true gem containing lots of bonus materials including a question/answer session with Veronica Roth, quotations that inspired Divergent, the novel’s playlist, writing tips from the author,  discussion questions, Veronica Roth’s thoughts on the dystopian genre and faction naming, a faction quiz, and each faction’s manifesto.



Plot Summary

Sixteen-year-old Beatrice lives in a world ruled first by one’s faction and then one’s family. Because of a devastating past war five factions have come to dominate society each believing they have the solution to end war forever. Fortunately, all agree to coexist by agreeing that once a person comes of age at sixteen they will be allowed to choose the faction they wish to live in for the rest of their lives. As such, Beatrice must choose to return to Abnegation, the faction she was raised in or else choose a different faction ensuring that she will have little to no contact with her parents and brother ever again. In order to aid her and her classmates’ decision tests are administered to them the day before they must make their choice. Most receive a clear result however there are a few, including Beatrice,  who are labeled divergent, capable of belonging to more than one faction. To receive this result is hazardous to one’s health as divergents usually end up mysteriously dead or missing.  Ordered by her test administrator to keep her results a secret lest she join the dead, Beatrice must now decide where she truly belongs, in selfless Abnegation with her family, in brave Dauntless where she yearns to go, or in Erudite, arch-rivals to Abnegation. Wherever she goes she must keep her divergent status a secret and pass initiation unless she wishes to become factionless, an outcast to all.

Critical Evaluation

Divergent is a whirlwind of a read where readers will want to simultaneously skim the book to discover what happens next to Beatrice while wishing to take notes on all the different factions’ beliefs. Additionally, the book causes readers to analyze where they would fit best. Would it be in Amity, a faction that values peace and friendship or Dauntless, a faction that values courage? Could they hack it in Erudite where knowledge rules or Abnegation where selflessness is valued above all else? Maybe they could join Candor if they tend to be brutally honest? Even though Beatrice joins a particular faction readers do catch glimpses throughout the novel of the various other factions while being tantalized by the vague threat of becoming factionless. Roth reveals little about how the factionless live which works very well as it makes readers more anxious for Beatrice’s future as she struggles to claim a spot within her chosen faction.

Not only is the book’s plot well-paced and action-packed but the themes within the novel will cause readers to reflect on their own beliefs regarding war, non-violence, belonging, family, and friendship. Although reminiscent of The Hunger Games as both series contain civil war Divergent is a wonderful book in its own right as it hooks readers from the beginning and leaves them begging for more!

Reader’s Annotation

When sixteen-year-old Beatrice must choose which faction to belong to for the rest of her life she is torn between the selfless faction of her childhood and the courageous faction she has always admired.

About the Author

Veronica Roth is a true inspiration with two best-selling books to her name even though she is only twenty-four years old. She is currently working on the third book in the Divergent trilogy due out in October 2013. As a side note, if she had to choose a faction she would choose Abnegation.

To learn more about Veronica Roth visit her website here.

Genre

Dystopian fiction, Romance

Readalikes

Insurgent by Veronica Roth
·         The sequel to Divergent
Legend by Marie Lu
·         Another dystopian novel that features a militaristic class
The Selection by Kiera Cass
·         Although not nearly as well-written and decidedly fluffier than Divergent it features a female protagonist living in a dystopian world that must go through an elimination process

Tags

16 yr. old, courage, elimination, family, friendship, government corruption, power struggles, testing, twins, virtues, war

Awards Won/Lists On

2011—Goodreads Choice Award for Favorite Book
2011—Goodreads Choice Award for Best YA Fantasy & Science Fiction Book of the Year
2012—ALA Teens’ Top Ten Nominee
2012—Children’s Choice Book Award Nominee for Teen Choice Book of the Year
2012—YALSA’s Best Fiction for Young Adults
2013—Wyoming Soaring Eagle Nominee

ABC New Voices Pick
Amazon.com Beat Ya Books of the Year
Chapter/Indigo Top Teen Summer Read
IndieBound Indie Next List
New York Times Bestseller
Publishers Weekly Best Book
School Library Journal Best Book

Professional Reviews






Publishers Weekly (starred review)

School Library Journal (Q & A session with Veronica Roth)


Booktalk Ideas

Which Would You Choose?
·         Abnegation
o   Selflessness
o   “Human reason can excuse any evil; that is why it’s so important that we don’t rely on it” (102)
o   Government leaders
o   War is caused by selfishness
·         Candor
o   Honesty
o   “Politeness is deception in pretty packaging” (81)
o   War is caused by duplicity
·         Dauntless
o   Courage
o   “Preparation eradicates cowardice, which we define as the failure to act in the midst of fear” (77)
o   Guards, security
o   War is caused by cowardice
·         Erudite
o   Knowledge
o   “Knowledge is the only logical solution to the problem of conflict” (Appendices, 43)
o   Teachers and researchers (43)
o   War is caused by ignorance
·         Amnity
o   Peacefulness
o   Values trust, self-sufficiency, forgiveness, kindness, involvement (Appendices, 37-38)
o   Farmer, counselor, caretakers (43)
o   War is caused by aggression

Bibliotherapeutic Usefulness

This book could be used for those who have lost family members through forced separation. It could also be used for teens exploring their core values and personality traits.

Reading Level/Interest Level

Reading Level: 5th grade
Interest Level: 9th-12th grade

These levels are according to AR Bookfinder

Challenge Issues

This book includes the following potentially controversial elements:

·         Attempted murder
·         Brainwashing//manipulation of free will
·         Bullying
·         Child abuse
·         Corruption
·         Graphic fist fights
·         Initiation exercises
·         Mention of sex
·         Murder by shooting others
·         Slight profanity
·         Taking Lord’s name in vain
·         War

Librarians can point out that while this book contains difficult elements it does portray civil war accurately. It also inspires discussions over what it means to belong to a group, the idea of family, and the place of non-violent resistance.

Why Was This Included?

While I did have to read a book from the dystopian genre I specifically chose Divergent because I had been wanting to read it for a while. I found the idea of factions fascinating and wanted to learn more about them in order to figure out which faction I would best fit into. I’ve decided that I would probably fit best in Amity or possibly Abnegation.